Share this :



Post on twitter:

 

When it comes to innovation, geography is destiny

 

Silicon Valley, by Matthew Hendricks

In the Feb. 11 edition of the New York Times, G. Pascal Zachary argues that where you are often trumps what you have when it comes to innovation. He points to the iPod, Google and Silicon Valley, suggesting geography makes the difference in determining who wins in the innovation game.

In explaining why Silicon Valley is more often than not at the centre of tech-innovation, Zachary writes, “Who wouldn’t want to play for a perennial contender? For the same reason that Andy Pettitte signs with the Yankees, the best and the brightest technologists from around the world make their way to northern California.”

A hat-tip to Wendong, a participant in the MaRS Entrepreneurship 101 series, for sending the article our way. In his blog, Wendong mentions Sir Peter Hall, the British scholar of urban clusters, who asks in “Cities in Civilization,â€? his history of geography and business innovation:

“The thought-provoking question at the end of the article is perhaps the central concern of MaRS right now: ‘What makes a particular city, at a particular time, suddenly become immensely creative, exceptionally innovative? Why should this spirit flower for a few years, generally a decade or two at most, and then disappear as suddenly as it came?’”

What do you think? Can places like Toronto compete with Silicon Valley? Can organizations like MaRS attract and create what Zachary calls “a network of seasoned pros” that can react to and commercialize ideas faster and more successfully than anywhere else? Are India and China threats to the reign of Silicon Valley?

  • http://www.polarwarming.ca Adam

    I agree that geography plays a certain factor in driving ingenuity. As a newcomer to Vancouver I have noticed that there is a large share of businesses in tuned to the environment and driving the shift to a “greener” Canadian economy. Maybe the natural beauty of the area is a driving factor to keep it so?

  • Bob

    Quotable quote: “The Bank of Nova Scotia doesn’t live there any more.” Source unknown.

    As a young Canadian and journalism student, I would urge the writer to make a greater effort to:
    1) prove your thesis, even if rather self evident and;
    2) “stoop to answer”: a humbling process (you might be wrong), as opposed to typical (arrogant) media pandering to hype, fearmongering, etc.

    The young journalist here gets us hyped up about the probable negative future of Toronto, hooks into typical Canadian worries about brain drain, throws in a great headline and somewhat unrelated quote and offers us no effort at finding any solution, or quoting from any optimist, (as distinct from cheerleader) who might lead the way. Then, leaving us hanging, wants the reader to do the work of actually thinking. Hey, its a dangerous business actually having an idea. People laugh at you, shout you down. But a professional would force him/herself to make the effort to create a better world, or to at least avoid damaging the one we have (fragile in many ways).

    The question raised is a quintessentially Canadian lament which all of us have a duty to answer. These days though, I’m fairly pessimistic that any Canadian can think about this or anything besides hockey.

James @ MaRS

James @ MaRS

James Koole is interning with MaRS while he finishes post graduate journalism studies at Humber College. When not onsite at MaRS, or on campus at Humber, he gathers endless amounts of information from wherever he can find it… much to the chagrin of his wife and two kids.

 
 
Get More From MaRS   MaRS NEWSLETTERS
Facebook Twitter Vimeo Flickr

MaRS Charitable Registration Number
876682717 RR0001

Please enter your email address to subscribe to our newsletter